Reporting frameworks

DEFINITION: A reporting framework is an independent tool designed to assist companies in preparing sustainability reports and ESG disclosures. Reporting frameworks require businesses to provide quantitative and qualitative nonfinancial information to supplement financial information to assess the prospects of the company. They enable all organisations worldwide to assess their sustainability performance and disclose the results in a similar way to financial reporting.

What are the business benefits?

Companies can realise a number of benefits from reporting on their sustainability information. The benefits can include influencing stakeholders to choose a particular company over its competitors. Customers, investors and employees may find this information important in their decision-making to work with, invest in, or work for an organisation. Being transparent on this information and asking for their views can positively influence their decisions. By integrating the most important materiality issues into the corporate sustainability strategy, reporting frameworks put in place structures and processes to allow for continuous improvement in performance.

There are a number of other potential benefits such as saving costs, identifying strategic and operational strengths and weaknesses, and working more closely with suppliers, improve internal processes and engagement with employees over sustainability activities.

What reporting frameworks are available?

There are a myriad of reporting frameworks across the globe, with almost 400 reporting initiatives identified in 64 countries.  There are a small number of standards considered to be the most credible by sustainability experts.

Global Reporting Institute (GRI) is the official reporting standard of the UN Global Compact, making it the default reporting framework for the compact’s more than 5,800 associated companies. It is among the oldest and most widely-adopted methodologies in the world.

CDP holds the largest list of corporate GHG emissions and energy use data in the world and is supported by almost 800 institutional investors representing more than $90trn in assets. Its transparent scoring methodology helps respondents understand exactly what is expected of them.

Membership in the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes (DJSI) is high-level as it represents the top 10% of the 2,500 largest companies in the S&P Global Broad Market Index. Its Corporate Sustainability Assessment brings a sector-specific focus and need-to-know simplicity to disclosure for public companies.

How do I know which reporting framework to choose?

The decision of which framework (or indeed which combination of frameworks) is most appropriate for a company depends on what information needs to be communicated and who the key stakeholders are.

Investors are the main target audience for DJSI, while the primary stakeholders of a GRI report are determined by the material issues for the business and typically include shareholders, employees, suppliers, regulators and NGOs.

Reporting frameworks have overlapping content as well as some major differences. The main focus of CDP is climate change mitigation and protection of natural resources. CDP therefore provides a structure for businesses to measure and disclose their greenhouse gas (GHG), water and supply chain performance. On the other hand, GRI looks at the economic, environmental and social impact of an organisation’s material activities on its stakeholders.

But it is clear there is some similarities. In May 2013, CDP and GRI signed a memorandum of understanding to form a partnership with the goal of improving the consistency and comparability of data between their frameworks. 

Any other key considerations?

Many experts agree that the sheer amount of standards and frameworks on offer to companies can cause confusion. For instance, the GRI, the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC) and the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), each have their own approach to how an organisation’s materiality should be determined, reported and assessed.

Even more confusing is when one framework, such as SASB, which is a compliance-driven approach to materiality based on the United States Security and Exchanges Missions, contradicts principle-driven approaches to materiality focused on a global framework, such as the GRI or IIRC.

As the GRI continues to publish linkage documents – how disclosures in the GRI guidelines (now transitioning to GRI Standards) match up to disclosures in other frameworks – and the Climate Standards Disclosure Board (CDSB) continues to squeeze the complexity of a multitude of reporting requirements into one massive cross-linked and cross-referenced matrix, companies are seemingly being expected to report against all or several of the frameworks and use linkage guidance to avoid duplicating data.

This make double work for companies who aspire to satisfy many stakeholders with one core data-set and one core sustainability report. In this environment, companies need to both understand and report and also report and cross-reference.

See also: Sustainability report

Related items

Take a look through all of the month's most-read news stories, and click the links in the descriptions below to read them for yourself

Plastics, Pledge Walls the potential 'death' of CSR: Top 10 sustainability stories of September 2018

Another month has passed which means it's time to remind ourselves of September's most-read sustainability stories and standout pieces of content from September - from massive plastic phase-outs and circular economy masterclasses to new supply chain commitments and a discussion about the future of CSR.

Delegates discussed the key drivers that would impact sustainability reporting in the near future

TCFD, SDGs and pop-up squads: What the future holds for sustainability reporting

Sustainability and corporate responsibility managers from a range of businesses recently gathered in London for an exclusive roundtable hosted by edie and reporting and assurance firm DNV GL to discuss how new standards, systems and stakeholder demands are together revolutionising sustainability reporting.

The UNGC believes that reporting on the SDGs must be

UN Global Compact: Corporates must stop 'cherry-picking' the SDGs

EXCLUSIVE: Large businesses will soon risk losing investor interest and stakeholder trust unless they stop "cherry-picking" which of the United Nation's (UN) Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) they report on and omitting negative impacts from their sustainability reports.

The debate around whether it is time to make the annual CSR report “disappear” continues to crop up among sustainability professionals

Academics call on businesses to drop standalone sustainability reports

A new report has urged corporates to drop standalone sustainability reports in favour of integrated reporting methods, to better showcase how sustainability can act as a holistic driver for growth and value across a business.

Achieving the Sustainable Development Goals: A Blueprint for Business Leadership

This brand new edie insight report provides clear, practical steps that can be taken by sustainability and CSR professionals to embed the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) within their organisation’s business strategy.

The hour-long webinar is available to watch on demand

Should businesses communicate negative contributions to the Global Goals?

EXCLUSIVE: As more companies pledge to support and report on the UN's Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), should businesses also examine and communicate negative contributions to the Global Goals?

(L-R): Presenter Corporate Register’s director Paul Scott; the Co-op team; and compere Rufus Hound

Meet the Sustainability Leader: Co-op - Sustainability Reporting 2018

With entries now open for edie's revamped 2019 Sustainability Leaders Awards, this new feature series will showcase the achievements of the 2018 winners, revealing their secrets to success. Up next: our 2018 Sustainability Reporting winners, Co-op.

Virgin Media is no stranger to using themed reports to make sustainability more revelant and accessible for stakeholders

Climate captains and sustainability strikers: Virgin Media unveils football-themed sustainability report

With England capturing the hearts of the nation at the 2018 FIFA World Cup, telecoms giant Virgin Media has released a new sustainability report utilising football themes to engage key stakeholders with its latest efforts.

The EAC does not believe that a voluntary approach will be effective in the medium-term

MPs urge UK Government to make climate risk reporting mandatory

Ministers have urged the UK Government to make it mandatory for companies and asset owners to report on climate-related risks by 2022 in order to "fix" the short-term mindset of the current financial system.

BT maintained its share of electricity generated from renewable sources at 82% last year - contributing a 5.4% year-on-year fall in its overall operational emissions

BT generates £5.3bn in revenue through carbon-combative products, again

BT's range of consumer operations and products which contribute to carbon savings were worth more than £5.3bn last year for the second year running, while the company also increased the amount of carbon it helped customers avoid by 1.3 million tonnes year-on-year.

Mission Possible: The 2018 report

Welcome to the future of sustainable business. edie's Mission Possible 2018 report has landed, exploring the key commercial drivers, challenges and opportunities on the road to a low-carbon, resource-efficient planet.

edie Explains: Smart grids

What is a smart grid and why is it important? What are the potential business benefits of the smart grid transition? And how mature is the smart grid concept in the UK? This free edie Explains guide gives you everything you need to know.

Gathering dust: Sustainability reporting experts are in agreement that annual CSR updates need to become a much more integral part of business strategy

Is it time to kill off the standalone sustainability report?

This week's Smarter Sustainability Reporting conference saw a number of industry experts discuss the evolution of the sustainability report, with some going so far as to argue that an individual annual report no longer carries the necessary impetus to drive change. So, is the age of the standalone sustainability report finally over?

The handbook offers advice on creating an engaging sustainability report and sharing it with key stakeholders

Seven steps to success: edie launches the smarter sustainability reporting handbook

With more stakeholders, staff and consumers demanding knowledge and information on corporate commitments, edie has published a handbook to help create an engaging and informative sustainability report.

The smarter sustainability reporting handbook

A new era is upon us: the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the Paris Agreement on climate change, the Modern Slavery Act (MSA) and the Task Force on Climate- related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) have together paved the way for an entirely new approach to corporate sustainability.

The priorities of citizens and businesses are often misaligned, the report warns

PwC: Businesses still not meaningfully engaging with SDGs

Up to two-fifths of businesses are still failing to engage meaningfully with the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), according to new research from PwC.

Sustainability Leaders Awards 2018 shortlist revealed!

After a record-breaking number of entries, the judging panel has met, the decisions have been made and edie is proud to reveal the finalists for the 2018 Sustainability Leaders Awards.