Lord Deben: ‘Climate change is the symptom, not the disease’

Lord Deben served as Environment Secretary in the 1990s and played an instrumental role in the Climate Change Act

Speaking at the virtual event, hosted in association with EDF Energy, Deben explained how the policymakers, businesses and the general public have become increasingly aware of what climate change means in terms of nature, the economy and social sustainability since the IPCC published its landmark report in 2018.

The report laid bare the differences between a 2C world and a 1.5C world in detail, for the first time. It concluded that global net emissions will need to reach zero by 2050 at the latest if the world is to have the best chance of staying within the 1.5C trajectory. As such, Deben called the battle against climate change “the battle for our existence.”

He said: “Climate change is the symptom of what we have done to the world. The disease is our loss of biodiversity, the way we have polluted the atmosphere, the way in which we’ve reduced the fertility of our soil, the green with which we have used our resources. And the disease is what we must put right.”

For Deben, a ‘green recovery’ from Covid-19 would result in the building of a society which is “much more milling to deliver a just transition” to a world in which humans are stewards of the Earth.

Fortunately, Deben remains optimistic about humanity’s odds of delivering climate action at the scale and pace needed.

“With the happy change of leadership in the US, we return to a situation in which nearly every nation on earth is committed to addressing climate change,” he said. The recent announcement from the Chinese, followed by the Japanese and the South Korean governments – compounded by Joe Biden’s determination to put the US back into the world community and support what is going on – does give us real hope that we can make a major change as we move towards COP26.”

Deben did have one word of caution, however: “All these commitments to dates and to net-zero and building back better mean absolutely nothing unless we do them. And, for me, the real issue is getting it done.”

Spotlight on the UK

Deben also provided a more in-depth view of the state of the net-zero transition in the UK, confirming that the CCC is on track to present its “crucial” Sixth Carbon Budget by the end of 2020.

He said that the budget, which will be the “toughest of all”, will give the government “a very clear path to follow” and provide businesses and individuals with “reassurance” about their ability to contribute to the transition.

“We are in a strong position to do a very tough job,” Deben added, reassuring attendees that net-zero can be delivered at 0.5%-2% of GDP.

He also spoke to the importance of the UK on the international stage, both as COP26 and as the place where the Industrial Revolution first began.

“We, among others, are a country that has grown rich off of the pollution that has caused climate change,” Deben argued. “Britain, in a sense, is the country which started it all, at a time we didn’t know what the downside was.

“Now that we know, we become responsible… we have to do what is necessary to stop disastrous global warming. We have a duty…. To recognise where our wealth comes from and, not to apologise for it, but to get on with putting it right.”

These comments come as nations prepare to submit updated Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) to the Paris Agreement. Boris Johnson is facing pressure from businesses, green groups and his own party’s MPs to lead by example and ensure the UK presents “ambitious” figures ahead of the deadline.

Join the conversation 

Registration is still open for Day Three (12 November) of Net-Zero Live. The event is free to attend and includes high-level keynote talks, interactive panel discussions, facilitated networking sessions and educational masterclasses, as well as virtual exhibition booths showcasing the cutting-edge net-zero technologies and services that will shape the decade ahead.

Register now to hear from representatives of Unilever, Timberland and many more. Click here for registration forms and for the agenda

Sarah George

Comments (2)

  1. C. Alvin Scott says:

    Hello, Just one major issue there with Lord Deben speech

    He relates to costs in terms of GDP that was, as of now, leading through December and January, we are seeing a clear contraction of the Industries and Corporations which means a contraction in GDP and Tax revenue.

    Al Scott

  2. Colin Megson says:

    The National Grid is on the same wavelength as the CCC in respect of the capacity of wind and solar plants (WASPs) they would like to see installed.

    One of the National Grid’s FES2020 Scenarios would require a capital investment of 18.47 billion per year, every year, starting now to get to zero-carbon by 2050. And because WASPs need decommissioning and replacement plants built, every 20 to 30 years, that 18.47 billion would have to be paid every year, forever! And that’s about 0.9% of GDP.

    Rolls-Royce’s first 440 MW nuclear power plant (NPP) will be operational in 2029. Starting 2030, plants capacity could be installed by 2050 to reach the same level of generation, for a capital investment of 12.42 billion per year, but just for 20 years. Then, because of the 60 years lifespan of NPPs, there would be a 40 years hiatus before investment was required again. That equates to 4.06 billion per year, or less than 0.2% of GDP.

    The NPP solution well cost almost 80% less than the WASP solution. That will make a huge difference to the low-paid and disadvantaged in our society, Lord Deben.


Action inspires action. Stay ahead of the curve with sustainability and energy newsletters from edie