Mary Robinson: Business and governments must avoid net-zero 'hypocrisy'

EXCLUSIVE: The former president of Ireland Mary Robinson has claimed that net-zero commitments made by governments and corporates must lead to a "just transition" that also combats the "hypocrisy" of ignoring fossil fuel developments further afield.

Robinson said that nations couldn't look to make themselves net-zero while continuing to fund polluting projects in developing countries

Robinson said that nations couldn't look to make themselves net-zero while continuing to fund polluting projects in developing countries

Robinson, an ex-UN commissioner for human rights who has twice served as a UN climate envoy, expressed her disappointment in the “lack of action that really counts” in the global effort to mitigate the climate crisis. She was speaking exclusively to edie on the day that UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson launched the COP26 climate conference strategy, pledging to deliver a “year of climate action” in the build-up to the conference in Glasgow later this year.

Like many, Robinson welcomed the UK’s net-zero emissions target for 2050, which has been enshrined into law. However, she warned that net-zero targets shouldn’t be built on “hypocrisy” that sees a nation focus on decarbonising while supporting fossil fuels in developing countries.

This has been evident in the UK. While ministers are keen to badge the net-zero target as “world-leading”, the Guardian recently revealed that almost £2bn in UK funding went to oil and gas in African countries, despite the UK pledging to propel clean energy in the continent.

“In 2020, we need, if possible, to have every country, every corporation and every city commit to zero carbon by 2050 and work backwards,” Robinson said. “If we could achieve that we’re really on course.”

“We need all the leadership we can get between now and Glasgow. We have to see the G20 as a whole to commit to going much further. We have to stop thinking we can be carbon-neutral in the UK and invest in oil exploration outside the UK. That’s not good enough, that’s hypocrisy.”

The European Commission’s Just Transition Fund is intended to support regions that will be particularly affected by the changes brought by ‘greening’ the economy and supports the bloc’s mooted net-zero commitment. Robinson claimed these types of support mechanisms would be crucial in delivering a global response to the climate crisis, rather than the individual efforts of nations.

However, the Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) submitted by nations as part of the Paris Agreement do not account for emissions outside of each nation's scope, an overlook described as a "flaw" by Robinson.

Business implications

Robinson noted that the same applied to businesses, who couldn’t use their financial power to support polluting sectors if they’d set a net-zero target. Microsoft, for example, has recently pledged to reduce its carbon impact to below net-zero by 2030, with an additional goal of removing carbon from the atmosphere that the company has emitted since it was founded in 1975. However, the tech giant is still inking major deals with oil industry giants like Chevron and Schlumberger.

Robinson echoed the growing notion for businesses to seek out the “real” zero, which focuses on regenerative value chains where businesses seek to rapidly decarbonise and improve the natural landscape across its global footprint.

Referencing her own Foundation’s work on “climate justice”, Robinson claimed that businesses should be supporting workers in the fossil fuel industry in transitioning to a green economy while empowering and supporting those most at risk to the climate crisis.

“Businesses reach through their value chains into communities,” Robinson added. “It does make a difference if you hear the account of a woman whose village is being undermined by drought or flooding and they need a group to fight back and be more resilient.

“We will not make the progress we need to make unless we fund a just transition. It’s not just workers in oil, gas and coal, but those working in the automotive industry too, we should be setting aside funds for reskilling, it is extraordinarily important.”

“Scientists made it clear that climate has put us in a very serious position and in this crisis we have to see the opportunity, we can no longer continue with business as usual. We have to be transformative and that will require real leadership.”

Matt Mace


| cop26 | fossil fuels | green economy | ethics | net-zero | low-carbon


Energy efficiency & low-carbon

Click a keyword to see more stories on that topic, view related news, or find more related items.


You need to be logged in to make a comment. Don't have an account? Set one up right now in seconds!

© Faversham House Ltd 2020. edie news articles may be copied or forwarded for individual use only. No other reproduction or distribution is permitted without prior written consent.